Chapter 40: The Best Honey Bread in the City (Allegedly)

Undefined Conviction

Chapter 40: The Best Honey Bread in the City (Allegedly)

Cole had a list. An actual, physical list, kept in the same notebook he used for nothing else, ranking every honey toast and honey bread establishment within a forty-minute transit radius on a scale that Reeve had once described as "unnecessarily scientific for a pastry."

"Sun-hee's place is still number one," Cole said, tapping the list with real conviction as they walked, sunlight cutting warm and lazy through a street lined with shops that had nothing to do with anything supernatural at all, which felt, lately, like its own small luxury. "But there's a bakery two neighborhoods over that a guy at school swears makes something called 'honey comb bread' that sounds like it might actually threaten the throne."

"You have a throne. For bread."

"Everything worth doing is worth ranking, Vesper. That's just science."

"That's not science. That's a personality disorder with extra steps."

"Same thing, dressed up nicer."

She rolled her eyes, but she was smiling, the small unguarded kind that had started showing up more often lately without either of them commenting on it directly. Mia and Reeve trailed a few steps behind, deep in an argument about whether honey bread even counted as breakfast food or whether Cole had simply willed an entire food category into breakfast legitimacy through sheer stubborn repetition, an argument neither of them showed any sign of actually wanting to resolve.

The bakery, when they found it, looked considerably older than everything around it — brick facade dulled by decades of weather, a hand-painted sign that had clearly been repainted by the same careful hand more than once over the years rather than replaced. Inside, warm and cramped, an elderly woman worked behind the counter with the specific unhurried competence of someone who'd been doing this exact job since before any of them were a consideration in anyone's plans.

"Honey comb bread," Cole said, practically vibrating with anticipation. "We heard rumors."

The woman studied him a long moment, something flickering behind her eyes that had nothing to do with pastry. "You've got the mark," she said finally, quiet, almost to herself. "Haven't seen one of those in a very long time. Not since before the Ashfall, and that's saying something, given how old I actually am."

Cole went very still. "You know what the Ashfall is?"

"Everyone my age does. Nobody your age seems to anymore, which I suppose is its own kind of mercy." She set a tray in the oven, unhurried, and continued like she was discussing weather rather than history. "Forty years ago. A city three provinces east of here — Kaelmoor, it was called — burned to ash in a single night. Not fire. Not war, not really, though it got remembered as one eventually. Something Convictions-related. Something that got out of control faster than anyone could contain, and left nothing behind but a name people stopped saying out loud within a decade."

"That's how the current Ministry started," Reeve said slowly, connecting pieces Cole recognized from Conviction Class, half-remembered footnotes that had never fully made sense until this exact moment. "The whole classification system. Licensing. All of it, built after something like that."

"Built because of something like that," the woman corrected, sliding a fresh loaf onto the counter, honey glaze still glistening. "The old system, before Kaelmoor, was looser. Wilder. People discovered their Convictions and just — lived with them, mostly unmonitored, mostly unafraid. Ashfall changed that overnight. Suddenly everyone wanted rankings, controls, a bureaucracy standing between ordinary people and whatever theirs might eventually become." She looked at Cole again, something careful and considering behind her weathered expression. "Marks like yours were common before Ashfall, they say. Considerably rarer after. Make of that whatever you like."

"Why would they get rarer?"

"Because whatever caused Kaelmoor to burn," she said, cutting the loaf into careful, even slices, "everyone who survived it agreed on exactly one thing afterward. Something wearing a mark like yours was standing at the center of it when the ash started falling."

This novel's true home is a different platform. Support the author by finding it there.

The bakery went quiet except for the oven's low hum. Cole felt the mark beneath his collar pulse once, faint and slow, like something old recognizing the shape of its own reputation finally being spoken aloud by someone who remembered it firsthand.

"You're saying people think marks like mine caused it," he said carefully.

"I'm saying people needed someone to blame, and marks like yours were rare enough, strange enough, to fit the shape of blame considerably easier than admitting the whole system might have simply failed on its own." She pushed the plate of honey bread toward him, gentle despite everything she'd just said. "For what it's worth, dear, I don't think blame and truth are always the same animal. I've lived long enough to watch plenty of things get blamed for causes considerably more complicated than the story anyone settled on afterward."

Cole took a slice, mostly on reflex, and found it genuinely excellent — dense, warm, honey soaked deep into the crumb rather than just glazed on top, immediately, seriously threatening Sun-hee's decade-long reign.

"This is incredible," he said, mouth half full, "and also possibly the most upsetting thing anyone's told me about my own neck in weeks, which is a genuinely competitive category lately."

"Sorry to complicate your pastry outing."

"Don't apologize. Best honey bread I've had all month, complicated backstory included at no extra charge." He set money on the counter, considerably more than the bread cost, and the woman didn't argue, just nodded once, like she understood exactly what the extra was actually paying for.

They ate on a bench outside, the four of them quiet for a while, honey bread demolished with considerably less enthusiasm than the situation deserved given how genuinely good it was. A bus rattled past, ordinary, indifferent, carrying people whose biggest worry that afternoon was probably whether they'd make their transfer, and Cole found himself watching it go with something close to envy.

"Kaelmoor," Vesper said finally, turning the name over like she was testing it against something buried and unreachable. "That name feels familiar. I don't know why."

"You think it's connected? To your missing years?"

"I don't know. Maybe. Or maybe every name from before Ashfall just feels familiar to me now because everything about my missing years feels adjacent to something that old." She frowned, frustrated in the specific way that had become her most common expression lately, a woman perpetually reaching for a shape just past her fingertips. "I hate this. I hate that every answer just points at three more questions."

"Welcome to my whole month," Cole said. "Population: everyone I know, apparently."

Mia, quiet until now, spoke without looking up from her bread. "If people forty years ago blamed something with your mark for burning down an entire city, and now the Ministry's watching you with the same fear, and the Choir's actively hunting people connected to whatever your mark actually is—" She finally looked over, sharp despite the honey glaze on her thumb. "Doesn't that mean whatever's coming isn't just about you, personally? It's about whether history's about to repeat something nobody currently alive actually understands well enough to stop it."

Nobody had an answer for that. The bakery's warm smell drifted out into the street behind them, ordinary and comforting, entirely at odds with the weight of what they'd just learned inside it. Reeve broke off another piece of bread, chewing slowly, working through something before he finally said it out loud.

"Forty years is close enough that somebody who survived it could still be alive and working now," he said. "Not just the bakery lady. Somebody in the Ministry. Somebody old enough to remember it firsthand and young enough back then to still be around, pulling strings, deciding what gets classified and what gets buried."

"Bellamy," Cole said slowly, the thought arriving cold and immediate. "He's old enough. If he was already the First before Kaelmoor even happened—"

"Then he might remember it," Vesper finished. "Underneath the smoothness. Somewhere in that crack you found."

Nobody said anything else for a while. The idea sat too heavy to pick up casually, the kind of thread that demanded its own dedicated unraveling rather than getting rushed through on a bench with honey crumbs still on everyone's fingers.

Cole's phone buzzed. Dana, texting fast and clipped: Aldric's custody request denied. Someone above Halden's clearance blocked it. He's exposed again by tonight.

"Well," Cole said, standing, brushing crumbs from his jeans, honey bread suddenly tasting considerably less sweet than it had thirty seconds ago. "Guess the honey bread tour's over for today."

"Story of our lives," Reeve said, standing too, already resigned. "Every good thing gets exactly one hour before something ruins it."

"Not ruins," Cole said, already moving, mark warming faint beneath his collar like it agreed there was somewhere else to be. "Just interrupts. There's a difference. We're getting good at telling them apart lately."

They left the bakery behind, honey bread bag still swinging from Mia's hand, and walked back into a city that had apparently been quietly rehearsing this exact kind of disaster once already, decades before any of them had been born to inherit the consequences.

[End of Chapter 40]