Chapter 36: A Face She Doesn't Remember Drawing

Undefined Conviction

Chapter 36: A Face She Doesn't Remember Drawing

Nobody touched the notebook again that night. It sat on the kitchen table between them, open to the same page, and everyone in the apartment gave it the specific wide berth people reserve for things that might still be dangerous even sitting perfectly still. Even Mia, who'd once dared Cole to touch a downed power line on a bet, kept a careful three feet of distance whenever she passed through the kitchen.

"It's definitely you," Reeve said, the next morning, squinting at it over a bowl of cereal he'd stopped eating twenty minutes ago. "Older, obviously. And your eyes are doing that gold thing in the drawing too, except — I don't know. Sadder. You look sad in it, Cole. Actually sad, not your usual performance of being fine."

"Thanks for the review."

"I'm just saying. Vesper's a good artist. Emotionally devastating, but good."

"I told you, I don't remember drawing it," Vesper said, arms crossed, standing a careful distance from the table like proximity itself might trigger something neither of them wanted triggered again. "Any of it. The rings, the shading, all of it. It's like waking up and finding a letter in your own handwriting that you have absolutely no memory of writing, addressed to a person you haven't met yet."

"Have you tried drawing something else? On purpose? See if it's just your hand doing this specific thing, or if it happens with everything now."

"I tried. This morning, actually." She pulled a second, ordinary sheet from her bag — a sketch of the kitchen, competent but plain, nothing hidden underneath it. "Normal. Boring. Exactly what I meant to draw. Whatever's happening with the other notebook only happens when I'm not paying attention to what my hand's actually doing."

Cole studied the older drawing again, careful not to touch it directly this time — last night's contact had cost him a nosebleed and a vision he still hadn't fully processed, and he wasn't eager to test whether round two came with worse interest attached. Instead he just looked, really looked, the way he looked at everyone and everything, cataloguing details without forcing a read.

The eyes were the worst part. Not because they looked wrong — because they looked exactly, unmistakably like something he recognized from the inside, a specific kind of tired he hadn't consciously felt yet but somehow already knew the shape of, waiting somewhere further down a road he hadn't walked to yet.

"I think it's not a memory," he said slowly. "I think it might be the opposite. Not something that happened. Something that's going to."

"That's a genuinely terrifying sentence to say out loud before breakfast," Mia said, from the doorway, arms crossed in her own smaller mirror of Vesper's stance.

"Sorry. Didn't want to workshop it first."

"Workshop it next time. For everyone's sake. Some of us are trying to eat."

They called Iris that afternoon, mostly because Cole had run out of people who might actually know something useful and Iris, despite eating his honey without permission on their first meeting, had proven surprisingly reliable about naming truths nobody else wanted to say out loud.

She showed up within the hour, unhurried as always, coat catching the afternoon light in a way that made the whole apartment feel briefly, incongruously fashionable, and studied the drawing for a long moment with an expression Cole hadn't seen on her before — not amusement, not boredom. Something careful.

Ensure your favorite authors get the support they deserve. Read this novel on the original website.

"I've seen something like this before," she admitted finally. "A long time ago. Not the same face, obviously. But the same quality. Convictions occasionally produce prophetic fragments in people close to a significant threshold — not fortune-telling, nothing that clean. More like water finding the lowest point before the rest of the flood arrives. If Vesper's this close to remembering something enormous, her hands might be leaking pieces of the future her memory's already half-attached to."

"That sounds made up," Reeve said.

"Most true things sound made up the first time you hear them. Ask literally anyone who's ever survived something impossible." Iris set the notebook down carefully, like it might bruise. "I'd take this seriously, Cole. Whatever's coming that makes you look like that—" she nodded at the sad, gold-eyed sketch, "—it's significant enough that reality's already started rehearsing the memory of it before it's happened."

"Helpful. Terrifying. Thank you."

"You're welcome." She studied Vesper a moment longer, something almost gentle entering her usually unbothered expression. "For what it's worth, dear — whatever you're circling toward remembering, you're not circling it alone anymore. That matters more than people usually credit it for. I've watched a great many people face something this large entirely by themselves. It rarely ends as well as it could have."

Vesper didn't answer right away. Just nodded, small and grateful, arms still wrapped tight around herself like she was holding something in rather than out. Iris let the silence sit a moment, then gathered her coat and headed for the door, pausing there the way everyone in Cole's life seemed compelled to pause in doorways lately.

"One more thing," she said. "If the drawing does come true — whatever it actually shows — don't waste time being afraid of it in advance. Fear spent early is fear wasted twice. Once now, uselessly, and once again when the real thing actually arrives and needs it."

She left before anyone could ask her to explain that properly, which had become, Cole reflected, something close to her signature move.

Later, once Iris had gone and Reeve and Mia had drifted off to their own corners of the apartment, Cole found Vesper on the fire escape again, their unofficial spot now, the same view of the same indifferent city lights spread out below them.

"You've been quiet," he said, settling beside her, close enough that their shoulders nearly touched.

"I keep thinking about the expression on your face. In the drawing." She didn't look over, eyes fixed on the skyline. "You looked like someone who'd already lost something and was choosing to stay anyway. I don't know how I know that's what it meant. I just do."

"Maybe it's not real yet. Maybe it never has to be."

"Or maybe it's exactly as real as anything else that's happened to either of us this month, and pretending otherwise is just a nicer way of being scared." She finally turned to look at him, something raw and unguarded behind her usual careful composure. "I don't know what I am, Cole. Not really. I don't know what I'm becoming, or what I already was, or whether the person who eventually remembers everything is still going to be someone you'd want standing this close to you."

"I'd want you close either way."

"You don't know that. You're saying it because it's kind, not because you actually know it's true."

"I'm saying it," Cole said, steady, meeting her eyes without flinching, "because I've spent a month reading people for a living, and the read I keep getting off you hasn't changed once since the day we met at the library. Whatever's underneath the missing years, whatever the notebook's trying to warn me about — the person sitting next to me right now isn't in question. That part's not a mystery. That part I already know."

Vesper didn't answer immediately. Just looked at him a long moment, something shifting behind her eyes that hadn't fully decided what shape it wanted to take yet, and then, slowly, deliberately, let her head rest against his shoulder the same way she had after the festival — except this time, neither of them pretended it was casual.

"That's a good answer," she said quietly. "I'm still scared, though."

"Yeah," Cole admitted. "Me too. Wasn't planning on saying that part, but there it is."

They sat together a long while, the mark beneath his collar quiet, the notebook's unfinished prophecy waiting patiently inside on the kitchen table, and for one more evening, at least, neither of them reached for it.

[End of Chapter 36]