Chapter 70: Incredible

Chapter update is here.

Find a quiet spot, turn the page, and let’s see what this story has been hiding 🌙

✦

"A forty-yard quarterback run!" Hammond shouted. "This rising senior has been nearly perfect since entering the game."

Collinsworth focused on the details.

"What I notice most is the unity on the West sideline. You can see pieces of the other quarterbacks in Callahan’s play. That is a special kind of All-Star generosity."

On the sideline, the three quarterbacks who had already played stood in a stiff row.

The camera found them at the worst possible time.

All three forced awkward smiles.

"I am so generous," Brad Ott said after a long silence.

Pat Barrett was less offended than amazed. He could not figure out how Nolan had copied so much so quickly.

Tommy Fraser spat into the wet grass under the camera’s gaze.

Coach Ladouceur was not smiling. His expression had turned serious.

He was about to send out the kicker for the extra point when Nolan waved toward the sideline and jogged close enough for a quick exchange.

"Bob Ladouceur and Nolan Callahan are both signaling from the field," Hammond said. "The West All-Stars are going for two. They want the lead right now."

"That means Callahan and his coach agreed," Collinsworth said. "The question is whether he shows us something new or keeps attacking with that running power."

In the huddle, Nolan explained the play quickly. The teams’ usual code words did not match, so he used plain football language.

"Option look. Running back alongside me."

Ali Abdullah, the West running back, nodded.

"Lincoln High runs this."

Like Nolan and Pat, Ali came from California. Pat had been the state’s top quarterback the previous year. Ali had been the state’s top player, which carried even more weight. He had produced eighteen hundred rushing yards and twenty-five touchdowns the previous season, and he could also play quarterback and defensive back.

Everyone in the huddle understood football well enough. Nolan did not overexplain.

The ball was snapped.

Nolan instinctively moved toward the front right.

Ali moved left.

Two players who should have mirrored the same action broke in opposite directions.

They both realized the problem at once.

In Nolan’s limited football vocabulary, the companion runner on that concept always started from the strong side, the side with the tight end. He had not known the weak-side version existed.

That brief hesitation killed the timing.

The other routes were designed as decoys and blocks. No one was cleanly available.

If the try failed, the West would still trail by one with very little time left. That one point mattered.

Nolan had no choice.

He kept the ball and went for the end zone.

The East defense had already reacted. At least four players blocked the lane. A two-point try offered almost no space. There was nowhere for Nolan to dance.

Those few yards looked farther than the forty he had just run.

Much farther.

But the arrow was already on the string.

Nolan launched himself forward with both hands on the ball.

The motion looked wrong at first. Not like a sprint. More like a run-up.

The first two defenders spread their arms to widen the wall. Experienced players could see that Nolan had no throwing lane and no receiver waiting behind them. He had only one option: come through.

Just before contact, Nolan tilted sideways.

For half a second, it looked as if he had lost control and was falling backward.

Then the defenders realized he was moving too fast along the ground.

He was not falling.

He was using the wet grass.

A baseball slide.

By the time the first defenders understood, they were half a beat late. Nolan slid through the gap. A safety behind them reached for him near the boundary, but Nolan’s path curved, stretching the distance and turning his body sideways.

At the last instant, he rolled across the line.

Nolan lay on his back in the wet end zone, rain striking his face.

Hammond’s voice tore through the stadium.

"He’s in!"

Collinsworth sounded almost reverent.

"That may be a two-point conversion people replay for years. The imagination to attempt that in this weather, in that space... remarkable."

If he had not been working on national television, he might have shouted something less polite.

The pity was that it was only a two-point conversion.

The greater pity was that it was an exhibition game.

If a play like that happened in a Super Bowl, the legend would never end.

"Before the rain," Hammond said, "we asked which player would adapt fastest. I think we have an answer."

"Nolan Callahan has shown an artist’s imagination in a football player’s body," Collinsworth said. "From an adaptability standpoint, he has become the leader of this All-Star Game, even with Peyton Manning’s reputation and those sixty college offers on the other sideline."

In front of the East bench, Peyton Manning looked toward the stands.

Archie Manning nodded from the first row. Cooper and Eli raised their fists in support.

Peyton held out his hand and watched rain collect in his palm.

Then he turned toward Coach Robert Davis.

"The field is too slick for a pocket quarterback," Peyton said. "Maybe we should let-"

He had not finished before Davis cut him off.

"No. In this moment, you are the only one with enough finishing ability."

"But-"

"No buts."

The backup quarterbacks closed around him too.

"We trust you," one said.

"We have your back," said another.

Peyton was pushed back toward the field almost against his own hesitation.

The final East drive began.

Peyton’s passing grew uncertain. Several chances opened and closed before he took them. Coach Davis saw the hesitation and prepared to make a change, but the moment had already moved past him.

On a throw from the West thirty-one, the rain ruined Peyton’s grip before his arm came forward. The ball slipped loose.

Alberto Rodriguez reacted first, using the same explosive closing move he had shown while tracking Nolan earlier. He crashed through the edge and forced the scramble, and a West linebacker fell on it first.

The East transitioned to defense quickly enough to prevent a return, but possession had changed.

Someone on the West sideline whistled.

"We won!" Pat shouted, holding up his hand.

Nolan slapped it.

"Hell of a job, Callahan."

"You just beat Peyton Manning head-to-head."

"You have to sign ten things for me. No, fifty."

Almost every teammate came over for a high-five.

They were happy, but not delirious. It was still an exhibition. The mood stayed light. A large part of the joy came from beating Manning at all.

Nolan looked toward Peyton as he walked off.

The East quarterback kept his head down, clearly shaken.

Would this break him?

Ladouceur chose Nolan for the final possession instead of Keith Smith, who still had not received meaningful time.

Keith explained before Nolan could object.

"Go back out. Take the applause. You earned it."

"In that case," Nolan said, "I’ll give this exhibition the ending it deserves."

Even Ladouceur looked bewildered.

"What else do you have?"

Nolan only smiled.

When he returned to the field, the stadium cheered again.

This time, it was for him alone.

An exhibition game was not the place for a kneel-down and a sterile victory formation. After the change of possession, Nolan gathered the offense and spoke longer than expected.

"They are taking their time in the huddle," Hammond said. "It looks like Callahan wants to show a special formation."

The players broke and aligned.

"Wait," Hammond said. "The back is split wide. Is he lining up as a receiver?"

"Three receivers and one back," Collinsworth said at once. "That is Peyton Manning’s look."

The two-minute drill was not a literal opening play. It was a compressed endgame offense: rapid calls, clock control, route adjustments, and pressure decisions stacked inside the final minutes.

For the offense, it demanded everyone move like parts of one machine.

For the quarterback, it was harder. He needed the routes, spacing, reads, and defensive responses running through his head at the same time.

This was not memorizing a script. It was adjusting the script while the defense tried to tear it apart.

That was one reason Peyton Manning’s finishing ability had become his calling card. Short calls, sometimes no calls, clean mechanics, and precise judgment. Steady, accurate, ruthless. Remove any one piece and the machine failed.

Nolan’s formation looked like imitation.

In truth, it required a high threshold to function at all.

If it were easy, every quarterback would be headed for the Hall of Fame.

Yet Nolan ran it with startling shape.

Inside the final ninety seconds, he completed another touchdown pass.

"Incredible," Collinsworth said softly.

This time, he turned off his microphone before saying anything else.

Both coaches on the sideline looked serious. In the stands, Archie Manning stared at Nolan without blinking.

Earlier, Nolan’s talent had been surprising.

At the end of the game, what he showed was something else.

It was frightening.

✦

✦

✦

Ready for more?

The next Chapters are already waiting on my Patreon, along with early access, previews, and extra story updates 🗝️

/cw/TheBacklotFanfiction