Chapter 140: A Truce Under the Walls

The news struck like two bombs going off in the same breath: a Vale army near Seagard, and Tully banners rising inside the Riverlands. Through the defenders of Pheasant Hall, already at the edge of collapse, and through the whole ruling structure of the west, the shock ran like an earthquake. Arthur, Diana, Smith, and every officer on the wall understood it in the same instant. They were no longer facing an assault from the front. They were caught on three sides, with a fire being laid in their own house.

Randyll Tarly learned of the Vale’s movements through his own scouts soon enough, and his first reaction was a soldier’s. Baelish had picked his moment well; whatever the fox wanted, the blow to western morale and the western rear was a gift to the army storming Pheasant Hall, and Tarly ordered the pressure increased at once, meaning to take the fortress in one stroke while the defenders’ hearts were shaking.

But on the morning he prepared to launch what might have been the final general assault, a fast rider brought a sealed order to his command tent, marked with Lady Olenna’s private signet, and its contents made even the iron lord of Horn Hill sit frozen with his brows drawn down. The Queen of Thorns had weighed the whole convulsing continent and reached a cold arithmetic of her own. Dorne was no longer a threat but a menace: the sun banners on Storm’s End meant Dornish power now touched the Reach’s own south, fat with new land and good ports, and a Dorne that digested the Stormlands would be a worse neighbor than the west had ever been. To bleed out against Arthur under these walls was to fatten Doran Martell for free, and perhaps to invite a pincer of north and south. The Vale’s stroke, meanwhile, cut both ways: Baelish’s appetite would not stop at a corner of the Riverlands, and a Trident in Littlefinger’s hands might serve the Reach worse than one in Arthur’s, for Arthur at least seemed bent on integration and defense, while Petyr Baelish was an expansionist to the marrow. And the west, though it had cost the Reach dearly, was visibly near its own end, its rear unsteady, its sea lanes threatened, its back newly knifed. To break off now was to end a war that cost more than it paid, with a decent face, and to turn the Reach’s strength south while the Vale and the west tore at each other.

So the order ran: halt the assault, hold and watch, and open a secret channel to the Lord of Casterly Rock to propose a truce. Tarly hated it, with the fortress a day from falling, and obeyed it, because he could read the same map. He reinforced his positions, chose his most trusted aide, and sent him across the lines under a white flag with his own letter and Olenna’s authority behind it.

When the envoy was brought up to him, Arthur was deep in council with Diana and Smith over the Vale and the Riverlands, and the offer surprised all three of them for exactly as long as it took to see through it. “They are afraid,” Smith said, licking cracked lips, his eyes bloodshot and bright. “Of Dorne. And of the Vale eating the scraps. They want out.” “Or it is a stall,” Diana rasped, “and they mean to watch us and the Vale cripple each other.” Arthur read Tarly’s carefully worded, quietly retreating letter in silence, looked from his two commanders to the Reach host beyond the walls, still drawn up in murderous good order, and weighed it. The Vale and the rebellion were swords hanging over the west’s neck; the front could ease and the realm still die from behind. A truce with the Reach was poison drunk against thirst, but it freed his hands for the fires in his own yard, and the Reach needed time for Dorne exactly as he needed time for his rear. And a truce, handled properly, was also a trade.

“See the envoy,” he said.

They bargained in secret, in one of the few unbroken stone rooms of Pheasant Hall. Olenna’s terms were, for a bled-white west, almost generous: immediate ceasefire on the present lines, the Reach to withdraw six miles and the west not to pursue, prisoners exchanged, the Reach recognizing Arthur’s rule over what he actually held, the west pledging not to attack the Reach’s borders, limited border trade, one year’s term. A decent peace, on its face. Arthur answered with his own floor: the Reach out of every occupied western territory entirely, including the infiltrators around Silverhill and Deep Den, back to the old recognized line from Old Oak to Pheasant Hall; the blockade and coastal raiding lifted, the sea lanes safe at least in their basics; a written renunciation of any Reach claim or meddling in the Riverlands, whose affairs belonged wholly to their warden; and the west’s pledge of non-aggression balanced by an explicit right to strike back at any violation of its lands, the Trident included.

The narrative has been illicitly obtained; should you discover it on Amazon, report the violation.

The envoy rode through the night, and Tarly and Olenna argued, and the envoy rode again, and after several rounds of hard bargaining a document was signed beneath the ruined walls by Arthur Greyoak and Lord Randyll Tarly for the Reach, which men would come to call the Pheasant Hall Truce. Its substance was compromise stitched with calculation. Immediate ceasefire; the Reach to withdraw from all occupied western territory within ten days, back to the traditional border, the old disputed strips excepted. The blockade of Lannisport lifted, though the Reach kept its patrol rights in the Redwyne Strait, which meant its shadow stayed on western trade. Prisoners exchanged. On the Riverlands, the Reach would not yet recognize Arthur’s full sovereignty, but pledged to respect the status quo and neither support nor incite rebellion against its warden. The west pledged one year without offensive war against the Reach proper. Designated border markets would open for limited trade. One year’s term, renewable by consent. Neither side got what it wanted most; neither surrendered what it could not live without; and between every line lay ambiguity enough to seed the next war at leisure.

On the day of the signing, the great host of the Reach began its slow withdrawal, and the defenders of Pheasant Hall, ground to the last edge of themselves, watched the tide recede. Many simply folded where they stood on the wall, weeping aloud or in silence.

Arthur stood above the gate and watched the distant dust, and there was no triumph anywhere in his face, only a weariness that went into the marrow and a weight that had grown rather than lifted. The truce was a breath, not a peace; the threats in front had merely stepped back, and the fires behind were burning now.

“Diana. Tally our losses, treat the wounded, repair the walls, and keep a hard watch. If the Reach turns back, I want to know before their horses do. Smith, rest and refit the Bannermen Guard, fill its ranks, then cut out an elite force and take it yourself to the Golden Tooth. Join Ser Rhaegar and make ready for the Vale and the rebellion both. Alwin, an urgent letter to Lord Jason Mallister: the truce is signed; he is to watch the Vale’s every movement, hold Seagard at any cost, and find out what Baelish has actually landed and what he actually wants. And send to every lord of the west and the Trident still loyal to me: muster and move on the line from the Golden Tooth to Seagard. Whatever this rebellion is, whoever stands behind it, it dies fast and it dies hard.”

The orders went out one on another, and the machine that had just finished one great battle turned, without cooling, toward a crisis that might prove worse. The thorns of the Reach had drawn back; the snake of the Vale was out of its hole; the Trident’s dark water had broken surface; Dorne’s sun burned in the south, the dragon and the lion tore at each other in the east, and the queen in King’s Landing sneered from her chair of swords. The Pheasant Hall Truce had not moved Westeros toward peace. It had opened an interval inside the storm, in which every power drew one breath, shifted its feet, and set itself for a harder collision.

Arthur came down from the wall with his shadow running long in the sunset. Over the ruins a fresh banner was rising, and beneath it waited a future more uncertain than the war had been. The truce was only that breathless, aching hush that comes before the storm arrives.